• Home
    • Manifesto
    • Submissions
    • Editorial
    • Essays
    • Reviews
    • Poetry
    • Interviews
    • Commentary
    • Imagery
    • Prose
    • Audio + Video
    • Classics
  • Publications
  • shop
  • Support
Menu

Red Wedge

Street Address
City, State, Zip
Phone Number

Your Custom Text Here

Red Wedge

  • Home
  • About
    • Manifesto
    • Submissions
  • Features
    • Editorial
    • Essays
    • Reviews
    • Poetry
    • Interviews
    • Commentary
    • Imagery
    • Prose
    • Audio + Video
    • Classics
  • Publications
  • shop
  • Support
10407539_10152673823050888_9094725755530288798_n.jpg

evicted art blog

Brecht and Benjamin on Moscow's Living Dead

July 22, 2015 Adam Turl

Bertolt Brecht was the most important German Marxist playwright and poet of the interwar period. He was a longstanding friend of the Marxist cultural critic Walter Benjamin. The following exchanges with (and quotes from) Bertolt Brecht were recorded in Walter Benjamin's diary in 1938 (while they were both in exile from Nazi Germany):

"There can be no socialist economy in any single country. The Russian proletariat was, by necessity, dealt a severe setback by rearmament—and, what's more, was thrown back to long-superseded stages of historical development. Monarchy, among others, In Russia, personal authority reigns supreme. Obviously, only idiots could deny this." (Bertolt Brecht, as recorded in Walter Benjamin's diary, 1938)

"Brecht was following the developments in Russia, as well as Trotsky's writings. To him, they were proof that there was reason for suspicion—a justified suspicion demanding a skeptical view of Russian affairs. Such skepticism was in keeping with the attitude of classical writers. If eventually it proved to be correct, one would have to fight the regime--and publicly, to be sure." (Walter Benjamin's diary, 1938)

"There's no doubt that on the other side, in Russia itself, certain criminal cliques are at work. Every so often, this becomes apparent from their horrendous crimes." (Bertolt Brecht, as recorded in Walter Benjamin's diary, 1938)

"No doubt about it—the fight against ideology has become a new ideology." (Bertolt Brecht, as recorded in Walter Benjamin's diary, 1938)

"Brecht reads me several polemical exchanges with Lukács—notes to an essay that he's going to publish in Das Wort. These are disguised yet vehement attacks. Brecht asks my advice concerning their publication. Since he also tells me that Lukács is now held in high esteem 'over there.' I say that I can't give him any advice. 'These are questions of power. Somebody over there ought to have an opinion on them. You have friends there.' Brecht: 'Actually I have no friends there at all. And the Muscovites themselves don't have any either—like the dead.'" (Walter Benjamin's diary, 1938)

"'In Russia, a dictatorship rules over the proletariat. So long as this dictatorship is still bringing practical benefits to the proletariat—that is, so long as it contributes to the balancing out between proletariat and farmers, with an emphasis on proletarian interests—we should not give up on it.' Several days later, Brecht spoke of a 'workers' monarchy'—and I drew an analogy between such an organism and the grotesque freaks of nature which, in the shape of horned fish or other monsters, are brought to light from out of the deep sea." (Walter Benjamin's diary, 1938)

"A Brechtian maxim: take your cue not from the good old things, but from the bad new ones." (Walter Benjamin's diary, 1938)

Brecht and Benjamin playing chess while exiled in Denmark, 1934

Helene Weigel and Brecht in 1938

Brecht with mask

Brecht brought before the House Un-American Activities Committee in 1947


Source: Walter Benjamin, Selected Writings Volume 3: 1935-1938, (Cambridge, Mass: Belknap Press of Harvard University Press, 2002), 335-341.


"Evicted Art Blog" is Red Wedge editor Adam Turl's investigation of potential strategies for contemporary anti-capitalist studio art.
← Tariq Ali + Stephen Parker on Bertolt Brecht (Video)Emory Douglas: The Epic Art of the Black Panthers →

WINTER ISSUE

download (3).jpeg

Most Recent

Featured
Nov 8, 2020
Listening for Mrs. Lynch: Left Culture as a Mass Matter
Nov 8, 2020
Nov 8, 2020
Sep 14, 2020
The Man Who Bridged Time
Sep 14, 2020
Sep 14, 2020
Sep 11, 2020
Dorohedoro through the Lens of Kafka and Marx
Sep 11, 2020
Sep 11, 2020
May 14, 2020
Salad Against Fascism
May 14, 2020
May 14, 2020
May 6, 2020
Neil Davidson, Cultural Theorist: A Personal Reminiscence
May 6, 2020
May 6, 2020
Apr 29, 2020
The Left Must Act Now
Apr 29, 2020
Apr 29, 2020
Apr 23, 2020
Corona Requiem + Other Poems
Apr 23, 2020
Apr 23, 2020
Apr 14, 2020
A Party of Our Own
Apr 14, 2020
Apr 14, 2020
Apr 9, 2020
Under an Alien Sky
Apr 9, 2020
Apr 9, 2020
Apr 7, 2020
Virus as Crisis/Crisis as Virus
Apr 7, 2020
Apr 7, 2020
Mar 9, 2020
Bad Moon Rising: Racism, Anti-Semitism + the Toxic Bernie Bro Trope
Mar 9, 2020
Mar 9, 2020
Feb 18, 2020
Winter 2020 * Partially Automated Dystopias + Utopias
Feb 18, 2020
Feb 18, 2020
Feb 18, 2020
A Partial + Schematic History of Red Wedge
Feb 18, 2020
Feb 18, 2020
Feb 18, 2020
Socialist Irrealism vs. Capitalist Realism
Feb 18, 2020
Feb 18, 2020
Feb 18, 2020
In its Right Place: Critique in the age of Spotification
Feb 18, 2020
Feb 18, 2020
Feb 18, 2020
Naked Souls: Imposition and "Nudity" in the Internet Age
Feb 18, 2020
Feb 18, 2020
Feb 18, 2020
The Formless Monstrosity: Recent Trends in Horror
Feb 18, 2020
Feb 18, 2020
Feb 18, 2020
Realism Modernism, + the Specter of Trotsky (part 3)
Feb 18, 2020
Feb 18, 2020
Feb 18, 2020
Lil Nas X: Old Town Rodeo for a New Power Generation
Feb 18, 2020
Feb 18, 2020
Feb 18, 2020
Hackers + Slackers: Encounters with Science + Technology in 90s Cinema
Feb 18, 2020
Feb 18, 2020
Feb 18, 2020
Stafford Beer: Eudemony, Viability and Autonomy
Feb 18, 2020
Feb 18, 2020
Feb 18, 2020
Don't Look Back: 1980s Music + The Counterculture
Feb 18, 2020
Feb 18, 2020
Feb 18, 2020
The Portions of the Day: Screen-Time + Time Discipline
Feb 18, 2020
Feb 18, 2020
Feb 18, 2020
Memez
Feb 18, 2020
Feb 18, 2020
Feb 18, 2020
Gentrification Is Coming + There Will Be Cupcakes
Feb 18, 2020
Feb 18, 2020
Feb 18, 2020
Water found on distant planet
Feb 18, 2020
Feb 18, 2020
Feb 18, 2020
Memorandum for HM Government FAO cabinet meeting re Commodity Fetish Outbreak
Feb 18, 2020
Feb 18, 2020
Jan 2, 2020
A Worker Reads Graphic Novels
Jan 2, 2020
Jan 2, 2020
Dec 27, 2019
An Announcement from Red Wedge – Can’t Stop, Won’t Stop
Dec 27, 2019
Dec 27, 2019
Red Wedge #6: In Defense of Transgression Buy on Amazon
RW-MAY1-ONLINE-SPLASH.jpg
Become a Red Wedge Patron

Become a Red Wedge Patron

Donate
Thank you!

about Red Wedge

become a sustainer

submissions

buy commodities

contact us

Subscribe